1 2

Pick Your Poison NSFW/After Dark Edition

$74.99
$74.99

Creative Conceptions Pick Your Poison NSFW game. Adult party game with 350 outrageous would you rather cards for up to 16 players.

Key Features:

Strategic voting mechanics create competitive gameplay beyond typical games

Massive 350 Poison cards deliver genuinely offensive adult content

Judge scoring system rewards reading the room correctly

Scales from intimate 2-player sessions to 16-person parties

Pick and Double Down cards add risk-reward strategy

SKU: NEW-9705
Availability: Out Of Stock
Product type: Sex Games, Coupons and Tricks
Please hurry! Only 0 left in stock

The Creative Conceptions Pick Your Poison NSFW/After Dark Edition is an adult party game that combines impossible "would you rather" scenarios with group voting and strategy. With 350 outrageous Poison cards, players compete by predicting what their mates will choose, making it a hilarious exploration of who is truly as messed up as you thought. Perfect for game nights that push boundaries and deliver genuine laugh-out-loud moments.

Pick Your Poison Specifications

  • Brand: Creative Conceptions
  • Game Type: Adult Party Game - Would You Rather
  • Card Count: 350 Poison Cards
  • Player Capacity: Up to 16 players
  • Contents: Game board, pick cards, double down cards, score sheet, house rules
  • Age Rating: 17+ only

Why Choose the Pick Your Poison Game

  1. 350 Ridiculous Scenarios: Every round feels fresh and outrageous. The Poison cards are genuinely messed up, making you discover which of your mates is just as warped as you.
  2. Strategy Built In: It is not just about laughing—you are trying to predict what other players will choose. That adds a competitive edge that keeps everyone engaged all night.
  3. Works for Any Group: Whether you are breaking the ice with new mates or cementing bonds with your crew, this game creates instant connection through shared chaos and genuine laughter.

How the Pick Your Poison Game Works

Each round, one player becomes the Judge and pulls two Poison cards. The Judge combines them into an absolutely brutal "would you rather" question—like choosing between participating in a nursing home orgy or donating half your paycheck to a hate group. The other players ask clarifying questions to really understand what they are choosing between, then anonymously vote for which poison they would pick.

The genius part is the voting. When players match the majority, they score points. When the Judge sees disagreement, they score instead. This means you are constantly trying to read the room and predict what everyone else is thinking. Combined with Pick and Double Down cards that let you take bigger risks for bigger rewards, the strategy layer makes Pick Your Poison feel like a completely different experience to simple party games. If you want something with real depth, explore our party dolls collection for other ways to elevate your gatherings.

Pick Your Poison Features

  • Massive Card Library: 350 Poison cards means you are not running out of new scenarios anytime soon. Every game feels unpredictable and fresh.
  • Real Competitive Gameplay: Voting mechanics create strategy. You are not just answering questions—you are reading people and making calculated bets.
  • Scales From 2 to 16 Players: Whether it is a small group or a full party, the game adapts. Pick and Double Down cards are included for larger groups.
  • Genuinely Offensive Content: This is an adults-only game with no filters. It asks the questions your regular party games are too scared to touch.

Adult Party Game Comparison

Game Type Best For What Makes It Different
Pick Your Poison NSFW Edition Groups wanting strategy mixed with chaos Voting mechanic and Judge scoring system create genuine competitive gameplay, not just laughs
Standard Party Games Casual groups avoiding controversy Limited content depth and no real strategy—mostly random outcomes
Drinking Games Blokes focused on alcohol consumption Pick Your Poison delivers laughs and strategy without requiring shots as the main mechanic

Who the Pick Your Poison Game Is For

Blokes After Real Laughs: If your crew loves Cards Against Humanity but wants something with more strategy and less randomness, this is your game. You will discover who your mates really are when they are put on the spot. Check out our adjustable cock cages collection for other ways to explore adult entertainment at your gatherings.

Game Night Organisers: You know those moments when the energy dips? Pick Your Poison reignites the room immediately. Players stay engaged because they are competing, predicting, and genuinely invested in what everyone else chooses.

Why the Pick Your Poison Game Delivers

This game is not trying to be cute or clever. It is raw, offensive, and genuinely hilarious because it does not apologize for what it is asking. The 350 Poison cards span everything from wild sexual scenarios to illegal activities to just plain ridiculous habits. There is zero filter, which is exactly what makes it memorable. Your mates will still be talking about what everyone voted for days later.

From the Community

Real experience:

I brought Pick Your Poison to a house party expecting it to be fun, but I was not ready for how it completely took over the night. Within the first round, everyone was leaning in, asking questions, trying to figure out what crazy scenario they would actually choose. The voting reveal moment is where the real magic happens—watching people's faces when they realize everyone has the same messed up sense of humor as them.

What got me was how it made the whole group feel connected. We were laughing until we could not breathe, but there was also this genuine moment where we all realised just how well we actually know each other. It is the kind of game that becomes the legend of your friend group. Mates are already asking when we are playing it again.

Explore More

Pick Your Poison is part of our collection of adult entertainment essentials designed to make your gatherings unforgettable. Discover more options in our breathable chastity cages range to find everything you need for adult fun.

Get the Pick Your Poison Game

Order the Creative Conceptions Pick Your Poison NSFW/After Dark Edition from MaleChastity.com.au today and turn your next game night into the stuff legends are made of. Discrete, secure shipping across Australia ensures your order arrives ready to cause chaos.

Malechastity.com.au ships with Australia Post. We ship from Sydney.

All in-stock orders placed before 12pm AEST (Sydney Time) on business days are generally processed on the same day. Packages are usually received 1-6 business days after shipping, but may subject to any postage carrier related delays beyond our control.

Free standard shipping on orders shipped within Australia above $200. For orders below $200 standard shipping within Australia is $12.95 and will be added at checkout.

Orders addressed to P.O box, G.P.O box or Parcel Collect will be handled by Australia Post. Extra time should be allocated for these orders.

Shipping Transit Times (Including Free Shipping)

Shipping time refers to the estimated time that it will take to deliver your order after it’s ready to ship (Please note this does not include time to process your order). Shipping time does not commence after your order is put through but begins the moment your order has been processed and is ready to dispatch via the our freight carrier..

1. Major City & Metro Areas (within Australia)

All in stock orders are generally processed on the same day the order was placed on business days for orders received before 12pm. Generally, orders are processed and shipped the same day or next business day.

Orders are typically received 1-6 business days after shipping. For larger packages please allow an extra 1-2 business days for delivery.

If no one is available at your delivery address to accept your order a second delivery may be scheduled or you will be notified that your order can be collected from the nearest depot location.

2. Rural Areas (within Australia)

All orders are generally processed on the same day the order was placed on business days before 12pm.

Generally, orders are processed and shipped the same day or next Business day.

Packages below 2kg are usually received 3-6 business days after shipping. For larger packages please allow an extra 1-2 business days for delivery.

If no one is available at your delivery address to accept your order a second delivery may be scheduled or you will be notified that your order can be collected from the local Australia Post depot.

International Shipping

The price for international shipping is AU$12.95 for orders equal to or below 0.399kg (399grams), and AU$22.95 for orders with a total weight equal to or above 0.4kg (400 grams).

All in-stock orders placed before 12pm AEST (Sydney Time) on business days are generally processed on the same day. Packages are usually received 6-30 business days after shipping. 

If no one is available at your delivery address to accept your order a second delivery may be scheduled or you will be notified that your order can be collected from your nearest delivery depot.

Please note in regards to all orders

– These expected delivery dates/times are based on carrier shipping practices, your destination, and the items in your order.
– Expected delivery dates are estimates. Orders can be delayed due to fraud verification or the time of the order being placed. Items that are not regularly stocked cannot be held to the expected delivery dates.
– Orders may be delivered in separate shipments.
– The order cut off times are based on normal Business Hours and exclude weekends and Holidays: Monday – Friday 12 pm
– When your order ships you will receive an email from us with a link to track your order.  If you receive your tracking number before 6 pm (AEST) it may not be updated on the Carrier’s website until that evening.

Due to large amounts of online credit card fraud, all orders are subject to approval by our payment verification department. We will notify you by phone or email should your order be delayed.

We have a 14 day return policy, which means you have 14 days after receiving your item to request a refund for any defective products.

Returns and exchanges are only available for faulty items, goods not as described, or in some instances, for incorrect sizing.

Due to health and safety regulations, Maleshastity.com.au cannot resell any returned or exchanged products.

This policy is in place to prioritise your well-being and ensure that you receive the highest standard of hygiene and quality in all products.

To be eligible for a refund, your item must be in the same condition that you received it, unworn or unused, with tags, and in its original packaging.

You’ll also need the receipt or proof of purchase. We do not issue refunds for change of mind or incorrect choice.

Under Australian Consumer Law, we are not obliged to accept returns for “incorrect choice” or “change of mind” so please choose your products carefully. 

Any freight and insurance costs to return the item to us are at your expense. This includes the liability for any lost freight – send via registered post.
If your return request is accepted, we will provide you with all instructions on how and where to send your package. Items sent back to us without first requesting a return will not be accepted.

Damages and issues

Please inspect your order upon reception and contact us immediately if the item is defective, damaged or if you receive the wrong item, so that we can evaluate the issue and make it right.

Exceptions / non-returnable items

We do not accept returns for any products that have change of mind, damaged products, or for products that have been used or do not have their original packaging.

Please get in touch if you have questions or concerns about your specific item.

Unfortunately, we cannot accept returns on sale items or gift cards.

Refunds

We will notify you once we’ve received and inspected your return, and let you know if the refund was approved or not. If approved, you’ll be automatically refunded on your original payment method within 7 business days.

Please remember it can take some time for your bank or credit card company to process and post the refund too.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Creative Conceptions Pick Your Poison NSFW/After Dark Edition and what type of game is it?
An adults-only party game featuring impossible "would you rather" scenarios, the Creative Conceptions Pick Your Poison NSFW/After Dark Edition combines 350 outrageous cards with strategic voting mechanics. Players compete by predicting what their mates will choose from brutal dilemmas, creating hilarious moments that reveal who's truly as messed up as you thought.
Which features make the Creative Conceptions Pick Your Poison NSFW/After Dark Edition more strategic than typical party games?
Strategic voting mechanics set this game apart from random party entertainment. The Creative Conceptions Pick Your Poison NSFW/After Dark Edition rewards players for matching the majority vote while giving Judges points for causing disagreement, creating genuine competitive gameplay where reading the room becomes essential for victory.
Are there enough scenarios in the Creative Conceptions Pick Your Poison NSFW/After Dark Edition to keep games fresh?
Massive variety comes from 350 Poison cards covering everything from wild sexual scenarios to illegal activities. The Creative Conceptions Pick Your Poison NSFW/After Dark Edition ensures every round feels unpredictable and fresh, with genuinely offensive content that pushes boundaries your regular party games won't touch.
Should couples exploring power exchange consider the Creative Conceptions Pick Your Poison NSFW/After Dark Edition for their adult gatherings?
Blokes after real laughs, game night organizers wanting guaranteed engagement, groups craving unfiltered adult humor, and anyone seeking strategic gameplay beyond random card draws will love this experience. The Creative Conceptions Pick Your Poison NSFW/After Dark Edition creates instant connections through shared chaos and reveals true personalities under pressure.
Which Australian store stocks the Creative Conceptions Pick Your Poison NSFW/After Dark Edition with discrete delivery options?
MaleChastity.com.au offers the Creative Conceptions Pick Your Poison NSFW/After Dark Edition with secure, discrete shipping across Australia. Your order arrives ready to transform game nights into legendary gatherings, with professional packaging ensuring privacy while delivering this adults-only entertainment straight to your door without judgment or embarrassment.

Related Products

Recently Viewed

Why Shop With Male Chastity Australia?

FAST ORDER DISPATCH

We ship same day on all in-stock orders placed before 12pm! Free shipping on all orders above $200.

DISCREET PACKAGING

All of our shipments come in discreet packaging ensuring those nosy neighbours will never know!

INTERNATIONAL SHIPPING

We ship our full range of products worldwide with fast dispatch for orders before 12pm Sydney EST!