Dual-size anal plug set in medical-grade silicone with tapered tips and suction cup bases. Progressive exploration for all experience levels.
Key Features:
Dual-size set enables natural progression from gentle to intense
Medical-grade silicone ensures body-safe anal exploration sessions
Suction cup bases provide secure hands-free positioning anywhere
Tapered tips guide smooth comfortable insertion every time
Waterproof design allows shower and bath play exploration
The Cheeky Butt Plug by California Exotics is a two-piece anal plug set in medical-grade silicone, with tapered tips and suction cup bases in small and large sizes. It suits men exploring anal play for the first time or seeking progressive intensity without buying multiple products. The dual sizing lets you control your own pace.
The Cheeky Butt Plug by California Exotics is built from medical-grade silicone that feels smooth and stays that way after every wash. Its two-piece design gives you a small plug for introduction and a larger plug for deeper sensation, so you are not locked into one size that might feel wrong. Most butt plugs come single-sized; this set eliminates that pressure.
Each plug features a tapered tip that guides insertion smoothly and a wide, flared base with a built-in suction cup. The seamless construction means no rough edges or seams where bacteria could hide. Non-porous silicone ensures thorough cleaning between uses, and the waterproof design means you can explore in the shower, bath, or anywhere else without hesitation.
Wash both plugs thoroughly under warm water with a gentle soap, then rinse completely and pat dry. Before insertion, apply a generous amount of Anal Lubricant to the tapered tip and around your entrance. Take your time; relaxation makes insertion easier and more comfortable. Start with the smaller plug to let your body adjust gradually.
Insert the tapered tip slowly, pausing if you feel tension. Once the widest part passes, the base will settle into place. If you are using the suction cup, press the flared base firmly against a smooth, wet surface (shower tile, bathtub wall) and it will grip securely. The first session should be brief — ten to fifteen minutes — so you can gauge how your body responds. Withdraw slowly and rinse everything thoroughly under running water.
This set works best if you want to explore anal play step-by-step rather than committing to one fixed size.
Great if you…Wash both plugs under warm water with mild soap immediately after use, then dry with a soft cloth. Store them in the included pouch or in a clean, dry drawer away from direct sunlight and heat. Keep them separate from other silicone toys to prevent discolouration. Check the silicone regularly for tears or damage; if you notice any, retire the plug to avoid injury.
Our guide on Butt Plugs For Gays covers insertion techniques, body readiness, and how to build comfort over time. For in-depth information on anal play safety and progression, that resource walks you through everything from warm-up to cleanup.
First-time users often find the smaller plug surprisingly easy to insert after a few minutes of relaxation and proper lubrication. The tapered tip does most of the work; your job is to breathe steadily and let your body adjust. The first session usually feels more like gentle fullness than intense sensation — that is normal and exactly what the smaller size is designed for. Many people feel surprised at how quickly discomfort melts into comfort once they stop tensing.
Progression to the larger plug typically happens within a week or two of regular use. The difference in sensation is noticeable but not jarring because you have already adapted to the feeling of an object inside you. If you jump to the large plug too soon, you may find it uncomfortable and abandon the set altogether; patience with the smaller one pays off.
Suction cup grip is strong on wet surfaces like shower walls and bathtub walls, but weaker on dry tile or completely smooth surfaces. Test your chosen surface before relying on hands-free positioning. Cleaning is straightforward — silicone rinses clean under running water and dries quickly, leaving no residue or odour.
Durability is excellent. Medical-grade silicone does not degrade from regular use, cleaning, or water exposure. The suction cups maintain their grip for hundreds of uses if you store the plugs indoors and avoid prolonged exposure to direct sunlight.
| Product | Material | Sizing | Attachment | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cheeky Butt Plug by California Exotics | Medical-grade silicone | Two sizes included (small and large) | Suction cup bases | Progressive exploration without buying multiple plugs. |
| Single small silicone plug | Medical-grade silicone | One fixed size | Suction cup base | First-time users who want to test waters with minimal commitment. |
| Single large silicone plug | Medical-grade silicone | One fixed size | Suction cup base | Experienced users who know larger sensation suits them and do not need progression. |
| Glass or stainless steel plug | Rigid glass or metal | Fixed size only | No suction cup | Users who prefer firmness, temperature play, or a completely different tactile feel. |
| Novice Prostate Beads | Silicone or other materials | Usually graduated sizes | String or retrieval cord | P-spot stimulation and prostate massage rather than pure anal filling sensation. |
Shop the Cheeky Butt Plug by California Exotics if you want to explore anal pleasure at your own pace without the expense or guesswork of buying one size too small or too large. Order it from Malechastity.com.au with discreet Australia-wide delivery. The dual sizing removes pressure, the medical-grade silicone keeps you safe, and the suction cups give you creative freedom. Start here. Service That Keeps Customers Coming Back.
Malechastity.com.au ships with Australia Post. We ship from Sydney.
All in-stock orders placed before 12pm AEST (Sydney Time) on business days are generally processed on the same day. Packages are usually received 1-6 business days after shipping, but may subject to any postage carrier related delays beyond our control.
Free standard shipping on orders shipped within Australia above $200. For orders below $200 standard shipping within Australia is $12.95 and will be added at checkout.
Orders addressed to P.O box, G.P.O box or Parcel Collect will be handled by Australia Post. Extra time should be allocated for these orders.
Shipping Transit Times (Including Free Shipping)
Shipping time refers to the estimated time that it will take to deliver your order after it’s ready to ship (Please note this does not include time to process your order). Shipping time does not commence after your order is put through but begins the moment your order has been processed and is ready to dispatch via the our freight carrier..
All in stock orders are generally processed on the same day the order was placed on business days for orders received before 12pm. Generally, orders are processed and shipped the same day or next business day.
Orders are typically received 1-6 business days after shipping. For larger packages please allow an extra 1-2 business days for delivery.
If no one is available at your delivery address to accept your order a second delivery may be scheduled or you will be notified that your order can be collected from the nearest depot location.
All orders are generally processed on the same day the order was placed on business days before 12pm.
Generally, orders are processed and shipped the same day or next Business day.
Packages below 2kg are usually received 3-6 business days after shipping. For larger packages please allow an extra 1-2 business days for delivery.
If no one is available at your delivery address to accept your order a second delivery may be scheduled or you will be notified that your order can be collected from the local Australia Post depot.
The price for international shipping is AU$12.95 for orders equal to or below 0.399kg (399grams), and AU$22.95 for orders with a total weight equal to or above 0.4kg (400 grams).
All in-stock orders placed before 12pm AEST (Sydney Time) on business days are generally processed on the same day. Packages are usually received 6-30 business days after shipping.
If no one is available at your delivery address to accept your order a second delivery may be scheduled or you will be notified that your order can be collected from your nearest delivery depot.
Please note in regards to all orders
– These expected delivery dates/times are based on carrier shipping practices, your destination, and the items in your order.
– Expected delivery dates are estimates. Orders can be delayed due to fraud verification or the time of the order being placed. Items that are not regularly stocked cannot be held to the expected delivery dates.
– Orders may be delivered in separate shipments.
– The order cut off times are based on normal Business Hours and exclude weekends and Holidays: Monday – Friday 12 pm
– When your order ships you will receive an email from us with a link to track your order. If you receive your tracking number before 6 pm (AEST) it may not be updated on the Carrier’s website until that evening.
Due to large amounts of online credit card fraud, all orders are subject to approval by our payment verification department. We will notify you by phone or email should your order be delayed.
We have a 14 day return policy, which means you have 14 days after receiving your item to request a refund for any defective products.
Returns and exchanges are only available for faulty items, goods not as described, or in some instances, for incorrect sizing.
Due to health and safety regulations, Maleshastity.com.au cannot resell any returned or exchanged products.
This policy is in place to prioritise your well-being and ensure that you receive the highest standard of hygiene and quality in all products.
To be eligible for a refund, your item must be in the same condition that you received it, unworn or unused, with tags, and in its original packaging.
You’ll also need the receipt or proof of purchase. We do not issue refunds for change of mind or incorrect choice.
Under Australian Consumer Law, we are not obliged to accept returns for “incorrect choice” or “change of mind” so please choose your products carefully.
Any freight and insurance costs to return the item to us are at your expense. This includes the liability for any lost freight – send via registered post.
If your return request is accepted, we will provide you with all instructions on how and where to send your package. Items sent back to us without first requesting a return will not be accepted.
Damages and issues
Please inspect your order upon reception and contact us immediately if the item is defective, damaged or if you receive the wrong item, so that we can evaluate the issue and make it right.
Exceptions / non-returnable items
We do not accept returns for any products that have change of mind, damaged products, or for products that have been used or do not have their original packaging.
Please get in touch if you have questions or concerns about your specific item.
Unfortunately, we cannot accept returns on sale items or gift cards.
Refunds
We will notify you once we’ve received and inspected your return, and let you know if the refund was approved or not. If approved, you’ll be automatically refunded on your original payment method within 7 business days.
Please remember it can take some time for your bank or credit card company to process and post the refund too.